Using Bayesian Reasoning to Predict When a Patient Will Discontinue Therapy

Can we predict with any accuracy whether an individual patient is likely to discontinue drug therapy? We're not talking about knowing if a patient has stopped using their meds, but if they're likely to do so. It might sound like something out of "Mission Impossible," but it's just data analytics at work in pharma. Yes, we're that cool.

This is regarding a presentation made at last year's PMSA conference by Jean-Patrick Tsang, founder and president of Bayser, a Chicago-based consulting firm dedicated to pharmaceuticals sales and marketing. JP is an expert in patient-level data and related analyses, and he's focusing on using a novel approach, Bayesian reasoning, to predict when a patient will discontinue therapy.

Look at the persistence curve of any chronic therapy and you'll invariably see a significant drop in the earlier stage of the therapy. We all know there is a slew of events that influence discontinuation. For starters, let's include factors like:
  • Admission to an ER
  • A visit to another doctor for a second opinion
  • A change in dosing
  • A side effect
  • An increased co-pay
  • The drug simply not working
  • Negligence (just forgetting to take it)
  • Psychology (If I'm taking medication, that means I'm sick.)
We know they have an impact but are not quite sure about the magnitude of the impact. We also sense that the impact of these events may not be the same if the patient is in the early stage or latter stage of the therapy.

Also, we cannot ascertain if the difference is limited to magnitude or also involves directionality. If we could somehow quantify the impact of an event on patient discontinuation while differentiating, say, between early stage (ramp-up) and latter stage (cruising), we would be able to establish which events are material and which ones are not.

We would then be able to focus on the important ones and identify relevant interventions both at the physician and patient levels that would significantly reduce the odds that the patient would discontinue therapy. We could gain additional insights by analyzing the impact on competitive drugs.

Enter Bayesian Reasoning

Bayesian reasoning is about how we update our belief in light of evidence. If we do not know much, we’ll assume that each patient has the same probability of discontinuing therapy. We can derive this from the adherence curve of the patient cohort we are tracking.

Using patient data, we know that patient 12345 who is under the care of Doctor John Smith has not filled the prescription for the last two months, has been admitted to the hospital, underwent a procedure, saw a second physician, has been diagnosed with a new diagnosis, was ordered a new lab test, or had another variable happen.

For each of the events, we have a likelihood that says how likely this is to appear if the patient were to discontinue compared with if the patient were to remain on the drug. We combine all the likelihoods and come up with a new probability of discontinuation that is specific to that one patient. This is called the posterior probability. We usually use a threshold to convert the probability into a yes/no answer.

Then What?

Many events that drive discontinuations have strong clinical rationale, including hospitalization and the seeing of additional specialists. But certain events may signal opportunities for intervention, including changes in dosing and change in the days' supply of the drug.

When we know patient 12345 is likely to discontinue with his therapy, we can have targeted interventions. It means contacting the patient's doctor. We can do this through visits from sales reps, emails and other forms of contact that will let the physician know their patient is likely to stop.

Takeaways:
  • We can predict discontinuations with high accuracy.
  • More work is needed to effectively triage at-risk patients to a specific intervention.
  • The analytical path to identify root causes can now be more focused.
"This is a success story that shows that we can indeed predict with great accuracy when a patient will discontinue therapy, which some still have trouble believing we can accomplish," said JP Tsang.

It's about explainability. We need to understand why the algorithm is saying what it's saying. Explainability is very difficult to achieve but we can start with transparency. Bayesian reasoning, we found out, strikes a good balance between accuracy (neural net) and transparency.


Comments (5)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! <a...

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! <a href="https://360digitmg.com/pmp-training-in-hyderabad">360DigiTMG</a>

Read More
 
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis 1 month after I turned 50. My grandma is 96 and had it since she was in her 20s. I have been on WORLDHERBSCLINIC MS HERBAL FORMULA, the first TWO MONTHS was daily and now I am on 3 times a week. It has...

I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis 1 month after I turned 50. My grandma is 96 and had it since she was in her 20s. I have been on WORLDHERBSCLINIC MS HERBAL FORMULA, the first TWO MONTHS was daily and now I am on 3 times a week. It has made a tremendous difference for me. The fatigue never gets to me again. When I do too much, I don’t feel weak anymore..

Read More
 
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Read More
 
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

https://www.google.com <a href="https://www.google.com">nice</a> BB KING keyword

 
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Air Jordan 11
Jordan 1
Jordan 5s
Air Jordan 3
Pandora Ring
Jordans 4
Jordan 1
Jordan 5
Jordan 13s
Jordans Sneakers
Birkin Bag
Golden Gooses For Sale
Jordan Retro 12
Air Max 90
Air Jordan 4
Jordan 12
Golden Goose Outlet
Jordan Retro
Jordans Retro
Lebron Shoes
James Harden Shoes
Nike Outlet
Jordan 11 For Sale
Golden Goose For Sale
Pandora Canada
Jordans Retro
Pandora Charms
Yeezys Shoes
Adidas Yeezy
Air Jordans
Air Jordan Sneakers
Mens Nike Shoes
Sneakers GGDB
Cheap Jordan Shoes For Women
Air Jordan Sneakers
Nike Shoes
Jordan 9
Nike Air Jordan 1
Jordan 1s
Air Force Ones Shoes
Adidas NMD
Nike Air Jordan
Golden Goose Sneakers
Triple S Balenciaga
Air Jordan
Nike Jordan
Jordan 13
Christian Louboutin Shoes
Asics Running Shoes
Pandora Ring
GGDB
Jordan 6 Retro
Air Jordan 5
Jordan Shoes
Jordan 11
Women Moncler Vest
Jordan 11
Jordan Retro 11
Louboutin Shoes
Jordan 6
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Jordan 11 Red
Air Jordan 1
Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping
Fitflop Shoes
Air Max 270
Jordan 6 Rings
Nike Official
Adidas NMD
Jordan Retro 11 Mens
Air Jordan 4s
Nike Air Max 98 Cone
Jordans 2021
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Jordan 11s
Red Bottom Shoes
Jordan Retro 12
Air Jordan Shoes
Moncler Coat
New Nike Shoes
Moncler Coats
Yeezy Shoes
Moncler Jackets
Nike Air Max 2018
Nike Shoes For Women
New Jordans
Kyrie Shoes
ECCO
Fjallraven Kanken Backpack
Air Jordan 14
Red Bottoms Louboutin
Ferragamo Shoes
Air Max
Air Jordan Retro 1
Vans
Golden Goose Mid Star
Air Jordan 3 Retro
Nike Outlet
Nike Outlet
Louboutin Shoes
Cheap Jordan Shoes
Air Jordans
Nike Outlet
Nike Sale
Nike Factory Outlet
Pandora Jewelry Canada
Soccer Cleats
Jordan 11's
Adidas Yeezy
Air Jordan 4 Retro
Pandora Jewelry
Jordan 1 Low
Yeezys
Jordan 6
Jordan Retro 12
Jordan Retros
Moncler Jackets
Air Jordan 1s
Jordan 1 High
Jordan 12
Air Jordan Retro 10
Pandora Jewelry
Golden Goose Shoes
Air Max 270 Dusty Cactus
Golden Goose
Balenciaga Sneakers
Moncler Jackets
Jordans Shoes
Jordan Retro 11
Huaraches Nike
Christian Louboutin shoes
Cheap Nike Shoes
Nike Snkrs Website
Red Bottom Shoes
Nike Shoes Outlet
GGDB
Sneakers Golden Goose
Jordan Shoes For Women
Christian Louboutin
Pandora
Nike Outlet Store
Jordan Sneakers
Christian Louboutin Heels
Air Jordan 4
Nike Air Max
Yeezy
Outlet Golden Goose
Air Max 95
Pandora Jewelry
Yeezy
Valentino Shoes
Air Jordan 8
Pandora Bracelets
Jordans 11 Retro

Read More
 
There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

  1. Posting comment as a guest.
Attachments (0 / 3)
Share Your Location
Type the text presented in the image below